[FFM] Our first threesome made me cum instantly

I've already told the story of fucking my cheating best friend, but I never gave her a name, so let's call her Ava. This story picks up in April 2018 after we'd been dating for about 4 months. One day while I'm at work and she's at school, I get a text.

"You know my friend Carmen?"

"Yeah"

"She's so cute"

Okay, I'm thinking that's gotta be some sort of trap, right? Ava and I had what you'd now call a situationship. We were both young, dumb, and didn't quite know how best to define a relationship. That being said, her bisexual desires for Carmen were well-known to me at this point. It was a frequent topic of discussion when I asked her about school.

I didn't want to sound too enthusiastic about agreeing with her, so I just responded, "she's alright. What about her?"

"I want to have a threesome with her"

Okay, that's definitely a trap... but on the other hand... Carmen was absolutely beautiful. Prior to me getting with Ava, when we were just friends, I remember her telling me that she had proposed the idea of a threesome with Carmen to her boyfriend at the time, who shot it down entirely. All I could think was, "don't fuck this up on the off-chance she's being serious."

"Well why don't you ask her then?" I asked.

"OK"

That was the last I heard from her until I went to pick her up at the end of the day, as I always did. She jumped in my car with extra enthusiasm and gave me a big, excited kiss.

"Guess what?" she asked.

"What?"

"She said yes!" I could tell from the smile on her face that she was being 100% serious.

"Wait, you really asked her?"

"I don't joke around about Carmen. She is adorable." Yeah, I can't really argue with that one. "Just to be safe we're all gonna get tested and she's on the pill so that's good."

"Wait, you guys actually like... planned this whole thing out, didn't you?" I was kind of dumbfounded. This went from maybe being a test to getting tested in the span of about 30 seconds.

As it turns out, Ava had been having threesome talks with Carmen for quite some time, and while she had expressed interest, was never fully into the idea when Ava was with her ex. I don't mean to be the "my girlfriend's ex was a douchebag" kind of guy, but... that guy was a douchebag, and everyone knew it. Carmen and I, on the other hand, always got along very well, so it was easier for her to agree to it when I was the third.

A few days go by, we get all the results back and everyone's clean, and we set up a date when Ava's dad is going to be out of town. The three of us went out, had dinner, went bowling, had a nice little time. I sometimes wonder if people looked at us and knew what was going to happen later that night, or if they just saw three friends out on the town.

It's about this point I should offer up some descriptions.

I was 23 years old, 6'3", white, dark hair, blue eyes, and a thin build that definitely made things down there look bigger than they were. Ultimately, I'm a little above-average in the length department but more above-average in thickness.

Ava was 19, around 5'7", white, dyed red hair, brown eyes, a little curvy, with big round tits, pierced nipples, and hips that popped. She's a very fun, goofy person who was always making faces to make me laugh. She was easily the naughtiest girl I've ever known, and I have dozens of stories with her worth telling.

Carmen was also 19, 5'3" max, light-skinned Hispanic, with straight black hair, brown eyes, a very cute face, and a laugh that any man would launch 1000 ships to war for. To this point, all my interactions with Carmen had me see her in a baggy shirt or hoodie, completely hiding her body, so I honestly had no idea what was underneath. She was a little more shy and reserved, which is most of what startled me about her accepting the offer.

When we got to the house and were finally in private, she opened up about it. Back home in Michigan, she was apparently a beauty pageant winner, which surprised me but also didn't surprise me. She had recently moved across the country to California, and wasn't really too familiar with anyone yet. She had a few hook-ups here and there, but nothing serious. She knew that Ava was interested in her, and was exploring her sexuality as well, having made out with a girl at a party just a few months earlier, and thought this would be a fun way to explore. All three of us said we had never had a threesome before, so it was a totally new experience for all of us.

It started with the three of us all sitting around the bed talking to each other and trying to get comfortable. I started touching Ava while we talked, rubbing my hands on her thighs, then up to her tits. After a moment, we started making out. I felt bad for poor Carmen, sitting awkwardly not knowing what to do. I pulled away, and asked if she wanted to kiss Ava next. The two girls approached each other with shy smiles on their faces and bright red faces. They kissed. I came up behind Carmen and started rubbing her shoulders to let out the tension. When they pulled away from each other, Carmen turned and kissed me next while Ava started to undress herself and pull my pants down. I tugged on the zipper of Carmen's hoodie and slowly pulled it off of her, followed by the baggy shirt underneath.

Holy. Shit.

This girl had the most amazing body I'd ever seen - fit, flat stomach, and a black bra holding surprisingly large tits on her 5'3" body, but not disproportionately large. Just perfect. Pair that with an exceptionally cute face, I now see what Ava's obsession was all about. I started kissing her neck and down to her tits.

"Carm, get down here," Ava called, and she obeyed. I was on my back now, pants off, cock hanging out, with both of the girls at the foot of the bed.

"Wow, you weren't lying," Carmen said.

"Yup! See? Enough for the two of us!" Ava said, and they laughed. She let Carmen have the first taste. She was shy about it at first, not out of inexperience, but I think just because of the situation. She was very good, and even tried to unsuccessfully deepthroat it at one point. Ava showed her how it was done with ease, and I was absolutely in heaven. They even did that thing you see in threesome pornos where each girl licks either side of the cock, their tongues meeting in the middle. How could this moment get any better?

"Wanna see how it feels in your pussy?" Ava asked. Carmen accepted with a smile. We did a little shuffling around on the bed. Carmen got on her back while Ava pulled down her panties. I stood up by the edge of the bed and positioned myself over her, and Ava got behind her to stroke her hair.

Now, dear readers, I must tell you a few facts of life. The first is that black-haired girls in black bras with flat stomachs and big tits are my weakness. The second is that there comes a time in every man's life when he has to muster up every ounce of restraint in his body to not cum as fast as he can and totally embarrass himself.

This was not one of those times.

As quickly as I had entered her, I was pulling out and shooting ropes of cum across her stomach. She was amazed. Ava was amazed. I was amazed.

After what felt like an eternity of silence, Ava broke in to say, "wowww, is your pussy really that good?"

"I think he liked it," Carmen said with a laugh. The girls looked at each other in astonishment.

"He doesn't do that for me," Ava said with an exaggerated pout, wiping a fake tear off her cheek.

"Lick up this mess, then have a taste of her for yourself," I told her, trying to sound commanding and manly to overcompensate. She instantly obeyed, and started licking my cum off of Carmen's tight body. I positioned myself to get head from Carmen so as to keep myself hard while Ava gave her head. With an experienced tongue working its way downstairs and a thick cock in her mouth, Carmen couldn't hold herself back for much longer than I had. After that, she admitted to needing a break, and stepped out to get some water. She bounced up off the bed, her tits jiggling while still wearing her bra. I watched her bare ass walk out the door, then turned to Ava.

"Okay, I like your friend Carmen."

"I told you you would!" she said, "now fuck me hard while she's gone. I wanna get as much as I can before she comes back and makes you cum instantly again."

She knew that would get a rise out of me. I spun her around, pushed her face-first onto the bed, then positioned myself behind her. When Carmen came back, she found me with a handful of Ava's bright red hair, slapping her ass with my free hand, and fucking her as hard as I could. We both liked rough sex and practiced it often, but we went extra hard here so that we could put on a show for our guest. Ava was screaming like I'd never heard before. Carmen laid down on the bed and started touching herself while we fucked.

I was glad when Ava came, because it meant it was time for my break. That shit is exhausting and my dick was practically numb, now a few minutes post-orgasm myself.

When I got back, Carmen was giving Ava some head that was later described as "good for a first-timer."

I walked up behind Carmen and slapped her on the ass, causing her to lift her head and look up at me with two big puppy-dog eyes.

"Ready for round 2?" I asked, and she nodded enthusiastically. She flipped over onto her back and spread her legs for me, as Ava sat on her face. She had taken her bra off at this point and I finally got to see her tits. Perfectly shaped and positioned, I almost thought they were fake if that wouldn't have been totally out-of-character for a shy girl only 19-years-old. With a more complete view, I could see a clear bikini tan line marking a contrast between her tanned body and pale tits.

I slipped inside her, all the way this time, and managed not to cum instantly. Ava leaned in to kiss me and whispered, "thank you for doing this." Yeah, you didn't have to ask me twice. Sensing that Carmen wasn't really into the face-sitting, she hopped off and opted to touch herself on the other side of the bed, watching us. I fucked Carmen with everything I still had in my body and occasionally peered over to watch Ava play with her tits and rub her clit. Carmen's tits bounced and rippled with every thrust, but I maintained my composure and kept fucking. At one point she propped herself up on her elbows and just watched my cock sliding in and out, totally enthralled by how much I stretched her pussy out.

At the time I thought she was trying to outdo Ava's screaming from earlier, but years later when I had a chance to fuck her again by myself, I learned that she absolutely was a screamer in bed, and a wild one at that. I don't know how no one heard her, especially when she came.

Finally I announced that I was about to cum again, and asked what we should do. Ava asked Carmen if she was still okay with going through with what they discussed while I was out of the room. Carmen enthusiastically agreed. I questioned what this plan entailed, figuring they wanted to do some kind of joint-venture.

"I want you to cum in her," Ava said. It sounds weird calling creampie/breeding a fetish since that's literally our biological function, but at this point, Ava and I both knew how much we each loved that. She also knew that I loved to hear a girl beg for it, and that's where the whole thing got ramped up to 11.

"Yes, cum in me daddy, fill me up!" Carmen yelled.

"Do it. Fuck your cum right into her pussy. Don't pull out this time."

"I want you so bad, I want to feel it pumping inside of me!"

1, 2, 3, shoot. There are few times in my life I have cum so hard as that one. Once the sensitivity wore off and I was finally able to pull myself out, I collapsed on the bed out of exhaustion. We all did. I think Ava ate her out a little bit more to get one last taste, but we were all pretty much done. We laughed and did what I call the "post-game summary," where we just talked about all the things that happened that surprised us about being in a threeway. Of course, my first cum was on that list, and I was happy to hear they both found it incredibly hot and it actually made them feel extra comfortable. A nice little moment to break a lot of awkward tension. Me ordering Ava to lick it off was also very well-received, and we all agreed that it was hot as hell.

We agreed to do it again, but it never really happened. Carmen entered a serious relationship shortly after, and Ava and I broke up. Though in the time between this story and that break up, I will tell you we had some mind-blowing sex, reinvigorated by this experience, and yes, she was eventually able to make me cum instantly again. She's still very proud of that every time we talk.