[M]y girlfriend and her [F]riends have a strange rule - Part 6

I had just taken the leap and suggested to my girlfriend Claire that we invite her friend Dani to join us in bed. Amazingly, Claire responded by moaning and kissing me. Just a few hours ago Claire had been furious when I told her I'd fucked Dani in the ass. And now my fingers were pressed against her drenched pussy as Claire moaned at the thought of me fucking her while staring at her best friend's ass. Talk about a reversal of fortunes.

I kissed my girlfriend back, thrown by the rapid turn of events. I wasn't sure if she was serious about having a threesome with Dani or was just guilty about the way she'd reacted last night. As I tried to untangle that thought, my brain conjured up an incredible image of Dani and Claire making out with my cock in between their lips. Fuck. I needed to make this happen. Instinctively, I pulled Claire closer and pressed my hard cock against her stomach. She gasped, grinding against me.

I pulled back and rubbed her clit gently, watching her writhe in pleasure. Desperate for her to say it out loud, I kissed up her neck and whispered in her ear, "Do you want Dani to join us?"

She gave a soft moan and nodded a little but kept her eyes closed. My heart began to beat faster.

I slipped a finger into her drenched pussy and elicited a moan. "Tell me what you want" I ordered. With her eyes still closed, she whispered, "I want to hear how you fucked her sir."

Fuck. Of course. I yanked Claire's t-shirt off so I had a good view of her breasts jiggling slightly as I began to describe my evening with Dani. I fingered Claire slowly as I told her about how slutty Dani had been, getting her tits out in the bar. I pinched her Claires pink nipples when I described Dani's nipple piercings and how I pulled on them to make her moan. When I got to the part about bending Dani over the balcony rail, Claire's eyes flew open.

I took my hand out of her panties and put my fingers in her mouth, making her taste herself as I told her about how Danielle had called me Daddy. Claire's eyes were wide as she listened, moaning on my fingers. Her hands went to the bulge in my shorts. She pulled my dick out and began stroking me frantically as I described how I fucked Dani's pussy.

I was desperate to get my cock inside Claire but the stakes were high and I made myself focus on Claire's pleasure. I noticed that Claire moaned whenever I told her how slutty Dani was so I described in detail how she had been behaving like a pornstar, with her over-the-top moans and the way she had sucked my dick.

At this point my cock had begun to throb. My super sexy memories of Dani combined with the sight my girlfriend getting off on them, meant I probably wouldn't be lasting much longer. I pushed Claire's hands away from my cock, took my fingers out of her mouth and flipped her on her stomach. She turned on her side to look back at me in confusion and began to say , "wha-?" Before she could get it out, I spanked her. Hard. She moaned and arched her back. I yanked her panties down, pulled her ass up toward me and slammed two fingers back into her pussy. Claire screamed and trembled as I fingered her roughly.

"You want to hear how I fucked Dani's ass don't you?" I said.

"Fuck..yes I do" she groaned.

"Yes what?!"

"Yes sir, please sir. I want to know how you fucked Dani's ass."

I pulled my fingers out of her pussy and spread her ass cheeks. As I stared at her perfect little asshole, I found it hard to believe I hadn't fucked it already. I brought my fingers to it. Claire had cried out in protest as my fingers left her pussy but her protest soon turned to a gasp as she felt me spreading her wetness on her asshole.

I gently pressed my index finger into her pink rosebud. Claire screamed and shuddered but she pressed her face into the sofa, raising her ass up to meet me. Her asshole was unbelievably tight, even more so than Dani's. I wiggled my finger in upto the first digit and Claire was moaning incoherently. Unable to take it anymore, I positioned my dick in front of her pussy and pushed in.

 

I groaned in relief as I finally started fucking her pussy. I spanked her again and brought my finger back to her asshole, pushing it in slowly.

As I thrusted, I told her, "Imagine my cock was in your ass instead of your pussy. That's what Dani got to experience." Claire moaned again and shuddered as I pushed my finger deeper into her tight asshole.

Before long I felt her pussy clench on my cock and I began to shoot my cum into her. After I finished I pulled out and collapsed backwards.

Claire remained completely still, her ass still in the air. I pulled her up towards me onto my lap. She was looking at me with this strange expression on her face, it was a mix between shyness, lust and wonder. I kissed her and waited for her to say something, it was strange for her to be so quiet. Finally I said, "so do you still think I'm not interested in your ass?"

"No" she shook her head and laughed.

I smiled and teased her, "but your ass so tight..I don't know if it can take my cock."

She looked up at me with a wicked smile and said, "I'll ask Dani to help."

Fuck yeah.

As you can probably imagine, I spent the next few days walking on clouds as I waited for the plans to be made. Although the actual business of Claire asking Dani hadn't happened yet, now that I knew that Claire was definitely on board, I was certain this was going to happen. I was sure that Dani wouldn't say no to an offer like this, not to mention that she'd probably find it very flattering.

As to what exactly the offer was, I wasn't very clear. Whenever Claire and I talked about it, by which I mean, loudly fantasised about it during sex, Claire spoke about it in terms of Dani "helping me" fuck Claire in the ass.

Didn't sound exactly like a typical threesome but I could hardly be disappointed. A few days later, Claire told me that she'd talked to Dani and Dani had agreed to help. My dick immediately began to twitch and Claire was practically ripping off my clothes as she told me this.

But since it was now certain that my dreams would be coming true, I decided it was time to finally clarify what exactly Claire was picturing. She really wasn't straightforward about these things, but I didn't want any misunderstandings. When I asked Claire, sure enough she seemed slightly annoyed and she said, "I don't want to plan everything..".

"But I need to know what you want, I don't want to accidentally upset you", I told her.

Finally she took a deep breath and said, "I know you want her more than me but you'll be fucking my ass not hers".

"You know that's not true" I tried to tell her that I was just trying to avoid a misunderstanding but she just seemed to get more annoyed.

Finally she sighed and said that I could touch Dani but not fuck her. I was pretty disappointed to hear it but I nodded. Honestly with everything Claire had given me I had no right to be disappointed. Besides, by the sound of it my fantasy of a double blowjob was still going to be fulfilled..

I kissed Claire and told her I understood completely. But she still seemed irritated. I was mystified but wasn't getting anywhere so I changed the topic.

Dani would be out of town for the next week, so the date had been set for the next weekend. There was certainly enough time for the anticipation to grow but Claire kept sending me mixed signals.

On one hand, she seemed extremely turned on by the idea of bringing another girl into our bed. We’d been fantasizing about it in an abstract way for a while now. In fact ever since she first revealed her cuckquean fetish to me, we'd begun watching porn as we fucked. And we'd discovered that what drove her particularly crazy was making me compare her body to the girls on screen.

She would prompt me with questions like, “Wouldn’t you rather be fucking her right now?” Or "Her tits are so much bigger than mine, aren't they?"

After some initial hesitation, I got into the flow of describing in detail what I’d do to those other girls while ravaging my sexy girlfriend. Claire had explained her cuckquean fetish in terms of wanting to be with an alpha man. But although she never explicitly said it, the jealousy and humiliation definitely seemed to be part of what got her off.

Ever since my encounter with Dani, the unbelievable sexiness of this scenario had now been compounded by the fact that the girl she wanted to be compared to was Dani. Although Claire had initially responded with anger and jealousy, she now seemed insanely turned on by the fact that I had fucked Dani’s ass before hers.

Now when we fucked, I'd often finger her ass and she'd say things like, "My ass is going to be disappointing to you after Dani's." And "It's going to be so hard for you to fuck my ass when Dani's is right there." It was enough to make me feel like I was walking through a minefield. I'd make some non-committal response and then she'd say, "her ass definitely deserves your cum more than mine."

Wtf?? On one hand, holy fuck is that hot. On the other hand, my anticipation for the threesome was souring a little because I was really unsure what Claire wanted.

And I didn't want to ask again and risk putting her off the whole thing. With just a few days to go, I texted Dani to see if Claire had been more candid with her about what she wanted. Danielle's reply was uncharacteristically short and to the point, "She wants you to push her boundaries ;) "