Two [FF]riends Fuck [M]e Back to Back Because of... FOMO?

We've all been there: down bad enough that we'll take any excuse to host a little get together and get your crush to come over. Well, little did I know my scheme would have my crush AND another character in my bed that night...

Met this girl at the gym. We'd say hey, spot each other a bit, and always take a little too long to say goodbye. She had thick thighs and a big ass from all the squats, always kept her curly blonde in a little half-up, half-down do. When I saw her out with a friend of my roommate, I knew I had my in. My roommate and that friend shared a birthday that was coming up, so it was a no brainer to host a joint birthday party and invite the gym girl.

Party starts and there she is, tight black jeans and a black crop top to show off the gains. But she didn't just come with my roommate's friend - an archetypal goth girl walks in with them. Curly red hair, multiple piercings on her face, she's wearing a blue flannel over some short shorts that reveal a thigh tattoo.

Party's fun, everyone's having some drinks, some chit chat, bit of dancing when a good song comes on. Some goofy party games. I have a quick dance with the gym girl and I can tell the vibes are right. But all the while I keep exchanging glances with the goth. I mean, who doesn't like a goth chick, right?

Eventually I make my move. When it's time to cut the cake, I hand the gym girl a slice between the crowd of guests jostling for a piece.

"Little cake for the cake" I say with a wink. She grabs the plate, but gets a lot of my hand in there and lingers on it for a moment.

"You have a sweet tooth?" she says with a little twinkle in her eye that I know means business.

"For some things" I reply, giving her strong elevator eyes. "You wanna grab a seat and eat? It's quieter upstairs." She bites right away and we head up to the bedroom.

Soon as we get in she sticks a finger into the cake and wipes off a dab of frosting. "Want a taste?" She smirks at me while outstretching her finger.

I grab her wrist and suck the frosting off her finger, pulling her waist into me as I do. She takes her finger out of my mouth and right away it's between my legs. She walks me back onto the bed which I find with my heels, sitting down. She undoes my pants and pulls them down - I'm already hard. She licks my stiff cock through my boxers as her hands run up and down my thighs.

"Always wondered what was under those Gymshark shorts" she says as she takes down my boxers. I'm already leaking precum as she takes me into her mouth, more than halfway down right at the start and then deeper soon after. Maybe it's because we were both a little tipsy but fuck she was going at it. I lean my head back and enjoy, but I'm already getting close. I push her off, then grab her by the chin and stand her up. I'm kissing her neck as I take her crop top off - her perky tits bounce right out as she didn't have a bra on. I kiss them and suck on her nipples as I bend down and take off her jeans. They're damn hard to take off because of those strong glutes and quads... but once I do I see she's not wearing underwear either.

Now it's my turn to sit her down on the bed. I push her shoulders and she lays back, raises her legs for me while I'm still standing off the side. I tease her lips with the head and feel how wet she is right away - she starts to squirm and inch herself closer to me. Finally, I slide the head inside, pause for a moment, and thrust the rest in. I'm nervous because from that head, I'm already close. But she lets out a moan right away and as soon as I start thrusting she's already shaking. She cums quick - thank god because I was about to bust. I pull out at the last second and spray my load all over her stomach and tits, with a few drops even reaching around her mouth.

We make out a little bit, have a couple minutes of quick pillow talk, and then she tells me she got what she came to this party for and has an early morning tomorrow, so she leaves. Hey, easy night for me, so I don't complain.

I go back downstairs but grab a pack of American Spirits out of my bedside table on my way down. I don't smoke much but sometimes it's just a vibe, you know? I sneak back downstairs and head onto the back balcony to light up.

A few puffs in a hear the door open behind me. "There you are," I hear a deep feminine voice say. The goth from before walks up. "Mind if I bum one?"

"No sweat" I say as I absent-mindedly hand her the pack, looking out over balcony.

She takes it and after a moment says "aren't you gonna light me up?"

I glance to the side and she's flicking her tongue along the butt of the cigarette like she's blowing it. I remind myself to get my mind out of the gutter, but I was literally just there a few minutes ago, so... I grab the lighter, and she leans in. Closer than she needs to. We get to chatting...

Eventually she says "you live here, right?" I nod. "Can I see your room?"

No way this happens twice in a night. But sure enough, I bring her upstairs, and pretty quick we're going at it.

At first I'm nervous. I literally just came, can I even get hard again? Do I, like, smell? But when she gets on her knees and looks up at me from underneath an eyebrow piercing, I feel the blood start to rush back down south and I relax a bit.

Now the head I got earlier was good, but this goth chick was something else. She takes me from half chub to rock hard in no time, and when I get there god damn does she make sure I stay there. Gagging, spitting, choking on me, she lets her spit drip down her chin and onto her tits. It's dripping down my balls, pooling on the floor.

"You like it sloppy like that?" She says, squeezing hard and stroking the head of my cock. Of course I nod, so she spits on it one more time and strips down naked. I do the same.

She kneels back down over the puddle of spit and wipes some up with her hand. She starts rubbing her pussy with it for a moment, putting on a show for me as I jerk myself off. She turns around, gets on her hands and knees, then reaches back between her own legs so I can see her playing with her clit from behind. I grab her ass with both hands as I start giving her backshots. Thank god I had already came because her pussy was so fucking tight. I fuck her harder and harder, I can feel my balls slapping against her fingers as she keeps rubbing her clit. The sight of her ass jiggling while I fuck her keeps me rock fucking hard. We're both getting sweaty, so I pull out to take a quick breath. She jumps off the floor and onto the bed, kneeling and pointing. I lay down. She mounts me and starts bouncing even faster than I was just pounding her. I'm mesmerized by how her tits move right in front of my face as he rides me. Eventually she asks for my cum: "give me that fucking load daddy" and god damn if I didn't cum almost right away. I push her off me, start cumming, and she right away starts stroking me to make sure she gets it all out. As I sit there, panting, she meets my eyes and licks my cum off her hands.

We lay in bed for a few minutes, my second round of pillow talk for the night. And that's when she breaks it to me.

"You know, I'm not the only one that wanted to fuck you at this party tonight." she tells me.

"No kidding?" I feign ignorance, but I get the impression that this'll all come out soon.

"What can I say, I get FOMO. When I heard [REDACTED] talking about how she was gonna seduce you at the pregame, I knew I had to throw my hat in the ring."

I don't know what was talked about among those friends the next morning... but that gym girl and I still chatted at the gym. Hooked up a few more times before I moved out of the area. All's well that ends well I guess, huh?